Monday, September 10, 2012

Reflection: Analysis of whole group data collected in first class. Writing Stages



            I also analyzed the second assessment for class 1 this week.  The assessment is based on DeFord’s developmental stages of writing.  On the assessment one student was at the “writing know isolated words” stages (stage 6), nine students were on the “Writing simple sentences: inventive spellings” (stage 7) and ten students were on “Combining two or more sentences, complete thoughts” (stage 8).  The students that were in stage 8 showed a strong understanding of storytelling and writing for a purpose but they did not exhibit strong control of capitalization and punctuation, as noted in the previous assessment of dictated sentences. 

Trends include:
  • All students showed errors with capitalization use.
  • All students showed errors with punctuation use.
  • Several students simple wrote a list of simple sentences with identical beginnings (I like…).


This assessment provided information about the writing stages of third graders.  One would expect for the students in the class to be close on the writing development scale due to similar instruction throughout the course of their schooling; this was true for the most paper.  The range of stages for the assessment was only 3 (all students were on stages 6, 7 or 8).  This supports the use of the assessment of dictated sentences to provide further information in order to select students for intervention.  The five students in each class who struggle the most will be selected for ten sessions of structured, research based intervention strategies.

Attachments:

No comments:

Post a Comment